Once More about Values and “Capital”

Once More about Values and “Capital”

Gutorov V.A.,

Professor, Head of Department of Theory and Philosophy of Politics, Faculty of Political Science, Saint Petersburg State University, gut-50@mail.ru

elibrary_id: 72442 | ORCID: 0000-0001-8063-2558 | RESEARCHER_ID: F-7724-2013

DOI: 10.17976/jpps/2020.03.09

For citation:

Gutorov V.A. Once More about Values and “Capital”. – Polis. Political Studies. 2020. No. 3. P. 126-143. (In Russ.). https://doi.org/10.17976/jpps/2020.03.09


The work presents the results of a critical analysis of G.L. Tulchinskii’s article Political Context of Narration with Karl Marx’s Wert-terminology: Cost vs Value (Polis. Political Studies. 2019 No. 3). In this article, a number of characteristic trends that arose in Russian political science at the post-communist stage of its development are very clearly revealed. The key focus of the author’s argumentation is a radical contrast between the value and cost traditions of the analysis of the text of “Capital” and the economic theory of Marx. On the contrary, modern works devoted to the knowledge economy and intellectual capital testify to the tendency towards creative interaction and mutual enrichment of both analytical paradigms, devoid of academic dogmatism. In this regard, in the author’s opinion, Tulchinsky’s ideological approach to the problem of values in Marxism at the present time is hardly capable of overcoming its traditional economical and ethical interpretations, examples of which are given in this article. 

political economy, values, Marxism, the Austrian school, ideological aberrations, intellectuals, academic discourse.


Althusser L., Ranciere J., Macherey P. 1966. Lire le Capitale. T. I. Paris: Francois Maspero. 256 p.

Althusser L., Balibar E., Establet R. 1966. Lire le Capitale. T. II. Paris: Francois Maspero. 401 p.

Assmann J. 2010. The Price of Monotheism. Stanford, Cal.: Stanford University Press. 140 p.

Bensaid D. 2009. Marx for Our Times: Adventures and Misadventures of a Critique. London; New York: Verso. 410 p.

Bounfour A. 2011. Le capital organisationnel: Principes, enjeux, valeur. Paris: Springer. 109 p.

Cutler A., Hindess B., Hirst P., Hussain A. 1977. Marx’s “Capital” and Capitalism Today. Vol. I. London: Routledge and Kegan Paul. 331 p.

Elliott G. 2008. Ends in Sight: Marx/Fukuyama/Hobsbawm/Anderson. London; Ann Arbor, MI; Toronto: Pluto Press. 160 p.

Fraser I., Wilde L. 2011. Marx Dictionary. New York: Continuum. 240 p.

Fritz K. von. 1984. Aristotle’s Anthropological Ethics and its Relevance to Modern Problems. – Fritz K. von. Beitrage zu Aristoteles. Berlin; New York: Walter de Gruyter. P. 69-91.

Gauthier D.P. 1963. Practical Reasoning: The Structure and Foundations of Prudential and Moral Arguments and Their Exemplification in Discourse. Oxford: Clarendon Press. 210 p.

Gouldner A.W. 1980. The Two Marxisms: Contradictions and Anomalies in the Development of Theory. Houndmills; London: Palgrave Macmillan. 408 p.

Handbook of Academic Integrity. 2016. Ed. by T. Bretag. Singapore: Springer. 1097 p.

Intellectual Capital for Communities: Nations, Regions, and Cities. 2005. Ed. by A. Bounfour, L. Edvinsson. Amsterdam: Butterworth-Heinemann. 368 p.

Keucheyan R. 2013. The Left Hemisphere: Mapping Critical Theory. London; New York: Verso. 304 p.

MacDonald B.J. 2006. Performing Marx: Contemporary Negotiations of a Living Tradition. Albany: State University of New York Press. 216 p.

Marsden R. 1999. The Nature of Capital. Marx after Foucault. London; New York: Routledge. 256 p.

McCarthy G.E. 1988. Marx’Critique of Science and Positivism: The Methodological Foundations of Political Economy. Dodrecht; Boston; London: Springer Netherlands. 226 p. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-94-009-2945-6

McCarthy G.E. 1990. Marx and the Ancients: Classical Ethics, Social Justice, and Nineteenth-century Political Economy. Savage, MD: Rowman & Littlefield Publishers. 342 p.

Organisational Capital: Modelling, Measuring and Contextualising. 2009. Ed. by A. Bounfour. London; New York: Routledge. 320 p.

Pettman R. 1981. Biopolitics and International Values: Investigating Liberal Norms. New York: Pergamon Press. 184 p.

Raz J. 2001. Value, Respect and Attachment. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. 178 p.

Rockmore T. 2005. After Marxism: Democratic Liberalism and Hegelian Recognition. – Democracy and the Post-Totalitarian Experience. Ed. by L. Koczanowicz, B.J. Singer. Amsterdam; New York: Rodopi. P. 51-60.

Scruton R. 2007. The Palgrave Macmillan Dictionary of Political Thought. Third edition. New York: Palgrave Macmillan. 744 p.

Social Costs and Public Action in Modern Capitalism: Essays Inspired by Karl William Kapp’s Theory of Social Costs. 2006. Ed. by W. Elsner, P. Frigato, P. Ramazzotti. London; New York: Routledge. 240 p.

The Uncollected Baudrillard. 2001. Ed. by G. Genosko. London;Thousand Oaks; New Delhi: SAGE Publications Ltd. 160 p.

Turner S.P., Factor R.A. 1984. Max Weber and the Dispute over Reason and Value: A Study in Philosophy, Ethics, and Politics. London; New York: Routledge. 274 p.

Weber M. 2019. Economy and Society. A New Translation. Ed. and transl. by K. Tribe. Cambridge, Massachusetts; London: Harvard University Press. 520 p. Westerman R. 2019. Lukacs’s Phenomenology of Capitalism. Reification Revalued. Cham, Switzerland: Palgrave Macmillan. 325 p. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-93287-3


Bikerman E. 1985. Institutions des Seleucides. (Russ. ed.: Bikerman E. Gosudarstvo Selevkidov. Moscow: Glavnaya redaktsiya vostochnoi literatury izdatel’stva “Nauka”. 264 p.)

Bol’shoi nemetsko-russkii slovar’ [Das grosse deutsch-russische Worterbuch]. 1980. Composed by E.I. Leping etc. Ed. by O.I. Moskal’skaya. Vol. I-II. Second Edition. Moscow: Russkii yazyk. 760 +656 p. (In Russ.)

Bohm-Bawerk E. von. 2002. Kritika teorii Marksa [Criticism of the Marx’s Theory (Zum Abschluss der Marxschen Systems; Die Ausbeutungstheorie)]. Moscow; Cheliabinsk: Sotsium. 283 p. (In Russ.)

Chuev F. 1998. Soldaty imperii: Besedy. Vospominaniya. Dokumenty [Soldiers of the Empire: Conversations. Memories. Documents]. Moscow: “Kovcheg” Publishing. 559 p. (In Russ.)

Epstein M.N., Tulchinskii G.L. 2006. Filosofiya tela. Telo svobody [The Philosophy of the Body. The Body of Freedom]. Saint Petersburg: Aletheia. 432 p. (In Russ.)

Frantsuzsko-russkii slovar’. [Dictionnaire francais-russe: 51 000 mots]. 1971. 6th Edition. Corrected and сompleted. Ed. by K.A. Ganshina. Moscow: Sovetskaya entsiklopediya. 911 p. (In Russ.)

Mayatskii M.A. 2010. Predislovie [Introduction]. – Gorz A. 2010. L’immateriel. Connaissance, valeur et capital. (Russ. ed.: Gorz A. Nematerial’noe. Znanie, stoimost’ i kapital. Moscow: The Higher School of Economics Publishing House. P. 6-9).

Hilferding R. 1923. Bohm-Bawerk’s Criticism of Marx. (Russ. ed.: Hilferding R. Bem-Baverk kak kritik Marksa. Moscow: Moskovskii rabochii. 74 p.)

Kozlowski P. 1999. Principles of Ethical Economy. (Russ. ed.: Kozlowski P. Printsipy eticheskoi ekonomii. Saint Petersburg: Economic School Publishing. 346 p.)

Schumpeter J.A. 2004. History of Economic Analysis. (Russ. ed.: Shumpeter I.A. Istoriya ekonomicheskogo analiza. In 3 vol. Vol. T. 3. Saint Petersburg: Economic School Publishing. P. 991-1665).

Tul’chinskii G.L. 2006. Biznes v Rossii. Problema sotsial’nogo priznaniya i uvazheniya [Business in Russia. The Problem of Social Recognition and Respect]. Moscow; Saint Petersburg: Vershina Publishing. 384 p. (In Russ.)

Tul’chinskii G.L. 2014. Rossiiskaya politicheskaya kul’tura: osobennosti i perspektivy [Russian Political Culture: Features and Prospects]. Saint Petersburg: Aletheia. 176 p. (In Russ.)

Tulchinskii G.L. 2019. Political Context of Narration with Karl Marx’s Wert-terminology: Cost vs Value. – Polis. Political Studies. No. 3. P. 174-185. (In Russ.) https://doi.org/10.17976/jpps/2019.03.11

V.I. Lenin: Pro et Contra. Antologija [V.I. Lenin: Pro et Contra. An Anthology]. 2017. Ed. by V.A. Gutorov. Saint Petersburg: Russkaya Khristianskaya Gumanitarnaya Akademiya. 860 p. (In Russ.) 

Content No. 3, 2020

See also:

Pakhalyuk K.A.,
Discourse Critique: Research Programs and Protest Practices. – Polis. Political Studies. 2018. No1

Yankovskaya G.A.,

Teterin A.Ye.,
Application of qualitative methods in political-science research (with N.Fairclough’s critical discourse-analysis as example). – Polis. Political Studies. 2011. No5

Kubyshkina Ye.V.,
US political discourse under the presidency of G. Bush Jr.: evolution of metaphors. – Polis. Political Studies. 2012. No1

Inoguchi T.,
Political theory. – Polis. Political Studies. 2012. No3



   2024      2023      2022      2021   
   2020      2019      2018      2017      2016   
   2015      2014      2013      2012      2011   
   2010      2009      2008      2007      2006   
   2005      2004      2003      2002      2001   
   2000      1999      1998      1997      1996   
   1995      1994      1993      1992      1991